God knows what makes the comparison
When “Empty Souls” was first previewed on the 2003 Isle of Wight festival, it was a fast and powerful rocker. That version continues to hold a vague kind of legendary status because it presented the song as a powerful rock number, with volume and energy that lacked from the eventual album version. The final recorded version has something the live version lacked completely, though: the gorgeous studio space.
“Empty Souls” towers with atmosphere. Each drum beat, each clink of the ice-cold piano (yes it’s very “New Year’s Day”, we get it) and each vocal line is shouted out into a gigantic area of space, echoing and resonating through the ether. It’s as if a grand stadium stage was set up in the middle of an empty valley: everything sounds colossal. James refrains from his usual guitar antics and swaps for an e-bow, a rarity from him: the electronically sustained notes radiate their own atmospheric touch, adding a haunting underline behind the melody of the piano. The whole song sounds immense, gigantic, something that looms over the sky with its presence.
Which is, naturally, what the lyrics also aim for. The lyrics describe loneliness and internal darkness so vast that nothing makes for an appropriate comparison: not even the Twin Towers attack, which was still fresh in everyone’s minds only a few years after it occurred and had become considered a collective trauma in the US and an inescapably terrifying event everywhere else in the world. For the radio edit the line was lazily changed into a comparison against dying flowers (lazily, because you can still clearly hear the backing vocals sing the original line), which is less controversial but also far less dramatic and not quite the point the line is trying to make.
The song became the second single for Lifeblood and in comparison to the tightly controlled campaign for “The Love of Richard Nixon”, the campaign for “Empty Souls” was a thorough disaster in every way and spelled the end for the entire era. Thanks to the abrupt sub-campaign for the 10th anniversary reissue of The Holy Bible, the single was pushed back all the way to January 2005, typically considered a dead month for music: the single made it to #2 but only because of its multiple formats and mostly because no one else was releasing new music at that point. Between the release month, the radio edit controversy and the mixed reception that Lifeblood had received the song barely got airplay; nor did the video get any time in TV, which may as well have been a mercy kill given its depictions of the band spending a bored night in a German hotel made for a truly terrible video. The band’s performance of the song in Top of the Pops ended with Sean throwing his drumkit on the floor, apparently due to frustration of having to succumb to a playback performance but it may as well have been the band’s opinion on how everything was going. The planned third single off the album was cancelled shortly after.
Another majestic victim of a badly managed campaign and a Manics classic that never became acknowledged as one, though it’s one of the few songs the band have played off the album in the years to come (rarely).
“Empty” Souls had a number of sleeve quotes: one for each of the three issues of the single and a fourth for the limited edition box you could order to store them in (mine’s #4559, albeit bought second hand). All reference physical death, which is another way to interpret the looming emptiness described in the song.
“The ceaseless labour of your life is to build the house of death”
-Michel de Montaigne
“After the first death there is not other”
-Dylan Thomas
“By the light of our insistent truths we wander into death”
-Edmond Jabés
“Death came and he looked like a rat with claws – I made him go into the wall”
-Jenny Holzer
The official video for some reason is not on Youtube, so I’m embedding the aforementioned TOTP performance.
[edited 19/09/22]